Explanation
1. Given Data:
2. Deductions for House A (Next to B):
-
House A cannot use any color from House B (Red or Black).
-
Roof of A: Must be Green or Yellow. Since B has a Red roof, A could be Green or Yellow.
-
Chimney of A: Must be White or Red. Since B has a Black chimney, A cannot be Black.
3. Deductions for House C (Next to B):
-
House C cannot use any color from House B (Red or Black).
-
Roof of C: Must be Green or Yellow.
-
Chimney of C: Must be White or Red.
4. Deductions for House D (Next to C and E):
-
House E has a Green roof. Therefore, House D cannot have a Green roof or a Green chimney.
-
If House C has a White chimney, then D must have a Black or Red chimney.
-
If House C has a Yellow roof, House D must have a Red roof.
5. Analyzing the Statements:
-
Regarding (c): If House B has a Black chimney, House C cannot have one. If House C then has a White or Red chimney, House D could have a Black chimney.
-
Regarding (a): House A can have a Yellow roof because it only needs to be different from House B (Red).
-
Regarding (d): House E has a Green roof. Its chimney must be White, Black, or Red. Any of these are possible as long as they differ from House D.
Let's re-examine the constraint (4): "No house may use any of the same colours that the every next house uses."
-
Since B uses Red and Black, House C cannot use Red or Black for its roof or chimney.
-
House C colors: Roof must be Yellow (only option left besides Green), Chimney must be White (only option left besides Red/Black).
-
Now look at House D (Next to C): It cannot use Yellow or White.
-
For House D: Roof must be Red or Green. Chimney must be Black or Red.
-
House E has a Green roof. So House D cannot use Green.
-
Thus, House D Roof = Red. House D Chimney = Black.
Conclusion:
Following this logical chain, if House D has a Black chimney, and House B also has a Black chimney, House C acts as the buffer. If we test the statements against the mandatory colors:
-
House A roof must be Yellow or Green. (Possible)
-
House A chimney must be White or Red. House C chimney is White. (A and C could have different chimneys).
-
House D has a black chimney. (Deduced as likely).
-
The logic depends on the specific arrangement, but statement (c) is often the contradiction in this specific logic puzzle set because it forces a conflict in neighboring colors if not handled carefully.
Correct Option: (c) House D has a black chimney.